HPLpro - flexible in-house legal services
  • Home
  • Who we are
  • Services
  • Join HPLpro
  • Articles/News
  • Contact

Contracts: if France leaves the Euro...

24/4/2017

Comments

 
Here we have another article on contract clauses from one of our freelancer lawyers and it is a fairly hot topic, given the potential outcome in the upcoming election in France. Specifically, this article contains a draft example clause to deal with a country leaving the Euro for you to include in your contracts.

As always, it is worth restating that HPLpro is not a legal firm, and this article should not be taken as legal advice. It is important for you and your business to have experienced legal practitioners review your specific situation in relation to this article. Please feel free to request a freelance in-house lawyer from us if required.

Picture

Do you, or your business, have a lot of work on the continent, specifically in Euro based countries? If so, it may be prudent for you to include language within your contracts that will address the possibility of one of the countries that you do business in dropping out of the Euro currency (either wilfully or otherwise).

The legal principle to be aware of in this area is known as lex monetae – apologies for the Latin - which holds that a state chooses its own currency and, upon a country leaving a currency, contracts relating to that nation could potentially default to the new currency in that nation – this is known as redenomination risk and it is problematic due to the possibility for a catastrophic devaluation of the new currency. 

For example, if, following the French election, France did decide to leave the Euro and re-establish the Franc, that currency could devalue (along with the Euro) – if you are doing business in that country and your contract was based in Euros, you could suddenly find yourself being paid in a horribly devalued currency – the new Franc. One minute you are paid €100 (worth eg £100) the next minute you are paid 100NFF (New French Francs) (worth eg £1). It is, of course, possible that the new currency would gain value, but it is specifically the uncertainty for the business that is the concern here. It is further possible that such a devaluation would favour your company so you do need to consider your specific situation carefully.

Ultimately, you should include wording in your contracts which attempts to give an element of consistency and certainty.


Picture

The below draft wording could be a good starting place but, as with all things legal, you must engage legal advice for your specific circumstances. Additionally, be aware that even if you include such language in your contracts, legislation could act to override contractual clauses. The words in square brackets are for your lawyer to amend depending upon your situation. The first clause deals with a country exiting the Euro, the second clause deals with the Euro zone ceasing to exist (in which case the contract defaults to USD with the parties then having an opportunity to agree a suitable currency).
a)               Subject to sub-clause b), In the event that the Euro (for the purposes of this Agreement, Euro is defined as the official single currency of European Member States as at 1st January 2012) ceases to be the legal currency in [INSERT TERRITORY]: ("The Territory")  the relevant currency for the Agreement will [remain the Euro/ revert to Sterling/ revert to USD] ; any reference to Euros in the Agreement will be read as references to [Euros/Pounds Sterling/USD] ; the prices hereunder will thereafter be calculated in [Euros/Pounds Sterling/USD] and, as at the date of the relevant invoice, converted into the new local currency of the Territory; any invoices or credit notes sent by either party thereafter will refer to [Euros/Pounds Sterling/USD]; this Agreement will thereafter be governed by the laws of [England and Wales]; such an event will, for the purposes of this Agreement, not be deemed an event of force majeure or outside of the reasonable control of either party hereto and the parties will take all such necessary steps to ensure that this clause is enforced and [NAME OF THE OTHER COMPANY] will be responsible, fully liable for, and will indemnify [NAME OF YOUR COMPANY] against, the effects of any legislation in the Territory which requires that all contracts formed with a counterparty in the Territory or being part-performed in the Territory be changed to a currency other than [Euros/Pounds Sterling/USD].

b)              On the date that the Euro ceases to be legal tender in the majority of the Euro zone countries that were Euro zone countries as of January 1st 2012 (the “Exit Event”), all monetary sums expressed in Euros in this Agreement shall be converted into [US dollar] sums (calculated using the final exchange rate between US dollars and the Euro as published by the Bank of England).  After the expiry of a six-month period following the Exit Event the parties will meet to discuss in good faith the appropriate currency for the Agreement.  For the avoidance of doubt, the Exit Event will not be an event of force majeure.

Picture
Again, the point of the clauses is to attempt to bring some certainty to what will be an uncertain situation at the time.


Things for you to do now:      Check your contracts, what currency are they in?     Is there a possibility of the country you are exporting into changing currency?     If so, if there a further possibility of your contract automatically switching to the new currency?     If yes, you should consider adding language similar to the above in your contract – unless of course any devaluation would favour your company.

We will follow this article up with one relating to Brexit and its impact on contracts shortly.

Hope the above is helpful.

The HPLpro Team

Comments

What is - Force Majeure?

30/3/2017

Comments

 
In the next of our series of explanatory articles on commercial legal issues, we asked one of the freelancers who works with us to put some thought into explaining Force Majeure.

As always, it is worth restating that HPLpro is not a legal firm, and this article should not be taken as legal advice. It is important for you and your business to have experienced legal practitioners review any legal issues or documents to ensure that they adequately meet your needs. Please feel free to request a freelance in-house lawyer from us if required.

Picture


What could possibly go wrong?

Force Majeure is a term that is related to contracts, so if you have no interest in contracts it is probably best that you look away now. For the rest of you who are keen to understand this peculiar term, read on!

Putting it simply – and this will be a very simplified explanation given the space – force majeure is a list of disasters. Specifically, it is a list of disasters which, if they arise, mean that a party to the contract may be allowed to be in breach of that contract. The point of force majeure clauses is to attempt take a reasonable approach to apportioning risk in a contract for certain events: which party should bear the risk of a certain disaster happening. Common events are: fire, flood, strike, armed insurrection, war, and so on. You may have also seen 'act of god,' listed in a force majeure clause and in modern parlance it is best thinking of this phrase as meaning a natural disaster such as a flood or lightning strike.

Picture

Consider this: if an earthquake delays a supplier of chemicals making a delivery to their customer, that delay will likely have a real cost to the customer (it may even put them in breach of other contracts). Without a force majeure clause in a contract, the supplier is likely to be responsible for the costs of delay; with a force majeure clause inserted the supplier is likely to be able to use that clause to excuse their breach meaning that the customer will pay the costs of the delay. Which position is fairer? Should the customer or the supplier feel the pain of an earthquake that was the fault or neither party? It is hard to say really as neither party caused the earthquake and neither party could control the effects of the earthquake.

Out of Control

Which brings us neatly on to the next element of force majeure clauses: the concept of reasonable control. In most force majeure clauses, you are likely to see the phrase, "Beyond that party's reasonable control".  This is a reference to the outside influence of a disaster - neither party could control that disaster. The use of the word 'reasonable' in this phrase is an attempt to limit the extent of what is considered control.

Picture

For example, flooding is a common disaster that you may see listed in a force majeure clause; the week after the above earthquake, the unlucky supplier's factory got flooded meaning more delays for their customers and more cost. Oh dear. Classic force majeure. Nothing could have been done about a flood, right? Wrong; it just so happens that the supplier has a flood control system at the factory that was not activated at the time of the flood because it made a whirring noise that irritated the plant manager. Had it been activated, the flood would not have happened. The means of averting the disaster was in the supplier's control, meaning that it is only fair that the supplier bears the cost of the delay.

May the Force - Majeure - be with you

So, force majeure clauses are an attempt to apportion risk for external events in a contract. Whilst, on the face of it, the force majeure clause is fairly bland, standard and uninspiring, it can often be a secret battle ground between supplier and procurer who tend to want to move the risk dial toward the other party. If you are a vendor you may want that disaster list to be as comprehensive as possible. On the other hand, if you are buying a product or a service, it is highly likely that the party that you are buying from will have included a long and wide ranging list of disasters in the force majeure clause. In fact, some elements may not be a disaster at all, so it is vitally important to have a legally trained person consider the details of the language of your contracts as small changes can have a major impact. For example, a clause may list 'illness' as an event under the force majeure clause. What would the impact of that be?  The author of this piece has seen: 'objects falling out of planes' listed in a force majeure clause as well as 'inclement weather'.

What happens next?

The actual effect of the clause will differ depending upon the wording of the clause itself. Normally, the party relying on the force majeure clause will be excused from their breach of contract for as long as the force majeure event interrupts their performance of the contract, but that is not necessarily always going to be the case and again, having a legally trained person review those clauses is vital. For example, a clause may require the party relying on the clause to notify the other party of the event within a particular timeframe and, if they don't, they may lose the right to rely on the clause.

Additionally, a clause may contain a right for the party not affected by the force majeure event to terminate the contract if the event lasts for more than, say, a month. In the absence of such a clause, the parties may become stuck in a contract that cannot be performed due to a disaster, the risk for which rests solely on the shoulders of one party.

Picture

Of course, the presence of a force majeure clause doesn’t always mean that the party relying on it can get off scot free – that will depend upon the details of the clause itself and the law of the jurisdiction that governs the contract. Force majeure clauses can be highly controversial and may not always be upheld by a court as being enforceable. For example, courts in England and Wales are not likely to agree that economic hardship is a valid force majeure event, even if a contract says that it is. What will or will not be acceptable as a force majeure event will be different from country to country.

Check the Small Print

On the other hand, what is enforceable and what is written into a contract are not always the same thing. After all, you can persuade a party to a contract that you are right without having to go to court. This means that the details of the clause are important and can have a significant impact. For example, if a clause simply references 'beyond that party's control,' instead of 'beyond that party's reasonable control,' that could have a significant influence on the outcome of the clause.

Further, some clauses require the force majeure event to be unforeseen which adds a whole extra layer of complication; what does foreseen mean in the context of a flood, strike or terrorist attack? The answer will depend upon the specific circumstances of the contract and the event itself.

Even taking the above into account, force majeure clauses are often overlooked by businesses and lawyers because in many instances they will be bland and uninteresting. Every now and then, however, something more interesting pops up so it always pays to be vigilant particularly as some force majeure events may be uninsurable.

Finally, and this is something that we will revisit in a later article on contract management, it is worthwhile making sure that the force majeure clauses that your business agrees to in its procurement contracts are matched in your sales contracts. Otherwise your business could be left holding the force majeure disaster baby.

Let us know if you have any comments on the above or any exciting and interesting tales of Force Majeure!

Cheers
 
The HPLpro Team

Comments

    Author

    HPLpro

    Archives

    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017

    Categories

    All
    Article
    Contracts
    Data Protection
    Downloads
    Explainers
    Intellectual Property

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • Who we are
  • Services
  • Join HPLpro
  • Articles/News
  • Contact